Cant get insured on a new car

I bought a Toyota Camry about 6 months ago and my insurance went up from $250-$300. I lived in Detroit where insurance is high so I didn’t think much. I had a Subaru before that was paid off but now the new car has a $10,000 loan on it so I figured the financing caused the increase.

I moved out of the city to somewhere cheaper and safer. My coverage ended so I tried to get insurance from the same provider but they declined to renew. Looking elsewhere I got a quote from Geico and they want $475 per month. All-State will not provide an online quote for my new zip code.

I don’t understand why my insurance has nearly doubled. Did something happen in the industry?