a question about cash app transactions

My roommate has a problem with stealing money from me. They do this by using my debit card info on cash app to send themselves money. I got a new card to stop this from happening. Today I see a new charge on the NEW card, she claims that it was an old transaction from a few days ago that went through late.

But I’m like 99% certain this is bs because my bank statement shows that it went through on the new card today. My question is simple: can cash app withdraw money from a new card that is connected to the same card used previously or am I being gaslit?

Thanks in advance for any advice/info.